What Your Property Manager Should Be Telling You Every Month (But Probably Isn't)

But if you're only hearing from them when something goes wrong or when it's time to collect their fee, you're not getting what you're paying for.

After years developing and repositioning multifamily properties in Los Angeles and Orange Counties, we've seen what separates property managers who protect investments from those who process transactions. The difference isn't service quality alone. It's tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars over the life of your investment.

Here are seven things your property manager should tell you every month — and what it's costing you when they don't.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

• 1. Deferred Maintenance Red Flags

Most property managers:  Wait until your water heater floods at 2 AM, then call with a $4,500 emergency quote.

What you should hear instead:   "Your water heater is 18 years old. Average lifespan is 10–12 years. We're budgeting $3,200 for planned replacement in the next 12–18 months. Here are three pre-vetted contractor quotes. Replacing on our timeline saves you roughly $1,500 in emergency pricing."

Emergency repairs cost 40–60% more than planned maintenance. A $3,000 scheduled HVAC replacement becomes $5,000 when it dies during a heat wave and you need same-day service.

We recently took over a 12-unit building in South Pasadena that had been professionally managed for six years. Within 60 days we identified $45,000 in deferred maintenance — aging HVAC systems, deteriorating plumbing, a roof with maybe two years left.

The owner asked the obvious question: "Why didn't my last manager tell me about any of this?"

Because most property managers don't inspect. They react. Our development background means we've built and renovated buildings. We know what to look for, what things cost, and what's about to fail.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

• 2. Market Rent Analysis

Most property managers:  Set rent based on last year's number plus a small bump. Maybe glance at Zillow.

What you should hear instead:  "Based on 47 comparable units within a half-mile, your 2-bedrooms are $150–200 below market. Here's the data. We recommend bringing units to market at turnover, with $75–100 increases for existing tenants to balance retention and revenue. Projected annual NOI impact: $14,400."

A typical scenario we encounter: a 30-unit building in East Pasadena, long-term tenants, minimal turnover. The previous manager kept renewing leases with $25–50 annual increases to "keep good tenants happy." When we analyzed the portfolio, market rent was $2,300–2,400 for 1-bedrooms. Tenants were paying $1,650–1,750. That's nearly $270,000 in lost annual income. Over five years, roughly $1,000,000 left on the table.

The nuance matters: you don't immediately raise rents $500 on good tenants. You bring vacant units to market, offer moderate increases to existing tenants, and upgrade during turnover to justify premiums. Strategy, not guesswork.

Your property manager should know what the unit three doors down rented for last week. If they need to "do some research," they're not paying attention.

Curious what your units should be renting for?

We'll run a free rent comp analysis for your property — no obligation, just data.

[Link to contact form]

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

• 3. Preventive Maintenance Schedule

Most property managers:  Fix things when they break. Send you the bill.

What you should hear instead:  "Here's our preventive maintenance schedule: HVAC servicing in April and October, gutter cleaning before rainy season, quarterly plumbing inspections, annual roof inspection. This month we completed HVAC servicing and caught minor issues on two units before they became failures. Cost: $340. Estimated emergency repair cost if we'd waited: $1,200–1,800."

The math is straightforward. A typical 12-unit building spends $3,500–5,000 annually on preventive maintenance. That same building spends $15,000–25,000 annually on reactive maintenance without prevention.

What gets skipped and what it costs: HVAC servicing at $150 twice yearly prevents $3,000–5,000 emergency replacements. Gutter cleaning at $200 annually prevents $5,000–15,000 in water damage. Plumbing inspections at $300 quarterly catch leaks before they become $8,000 insurance claims that spike your premiums.

We manage preventively because we've been on the ownership side. Spending $4,000 in Year 1 saves $40,000 over Years 1–5. That math doesn't change.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

• 4. Tenant Quality Metrics

Most property managers:  "Rent collected. See attached statement."

What you should hear instead:  "Current performance: 92% on-time payments, maintenance satisfaction 4.7/5, zero lease violations, 3.2-year average tenancy. Two leases expiring next quarter — both excellent tenants, recommending renewal with modest increases."

One eviction wipes out 3–5 years of profit on a single unit when you factor in legal fees, lost rent, turnover costs, and repairs. Yet most property managers focus on filling vacancies quickly instead of filling them correctly.

Our screening includes credit, background, eviction history, verified income (3x rent minimum), actual calls to previous landlords, and an interview. It takes longer. It's worth it. We've had units sit vacant an extra two weeks during screening — and the tenants we placed have stayed three-plus years with zero issues. Those 14 days of vacancy saved five figures in avoided problems.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

• 5. Property Condition Updates

Most property managers:  Visit when there's a problem. Maybe.

What you should hear instead:  "Quarterly walkthrough completed. Photo report attached. Items noted: exterior trim needs paint ($850 quote), seasonal landscape refresh budgeted ($600), Unit 7 weather stripping worn ($85, scheduled). Overall condition: excellent."

Our development background means we don't just notice problems — we understand root causes. Roof wear? We estimate remaining life. Drainage issues? We know the fix before calling a contractor.

We once took over a property where the previous manager had been "fixing" a persistent moisture problem for two years. Five contractor visits. Thousands spent. Problem persisted. We identified the actual issue in 30 minutes: exterior grading directing water toward the foundation. Fixed properly for $1,200. The previous manager had spent $4,300 on band-aids.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

• 6. Local Market Intelligence

Most property managers:  Manage your property in isolation

.

What you should hear instead:  "New luxury apartments opening on Lake Avenue Q3 — 120 units at premium pricing. Minimal impact on your tenant base due to price differential, but monitoring. Metro extension approved for 2027 — your property is now half-mile from a future station. Expect long-term value increase."

Your property doesn't exist in a vacuum. New development, employment shifts, infrastructure projects, zoning changes, and neighborhood evolution all affect your bottom line. Your property manager should track this and tell you what it means for your specific property.

Own properties in multiple cities?

Regulatory requirements vary significantly!

Read our California Rent Control City-by-City Guide [Link to Post 3] for what applies to your properties.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

• 7. Financial Performance Context

Most property managers:  Send statements. No explanation. You wonder if the numbers are good or bad.

What you should hear instead:  "March rental income $24,600, collected at 100%, up 3.2% year-over-year. Operating expenses $8,340 — higher this month due to scheduled HVAC servicing. NOI $16,260, up 8.1% versus last March. Year-to-date tracking 6.3% ahead."

"Maintenance was $3,400 this month" means nothing without context. Was it planned or emergency? Above average or below? Your property manager should tell you what the numbers mean, not just what they are.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

Do Any of These Sound Familiar?

You only hear from them when something's wrong.

High tenant turnover with no explanation.

Maintenance costs that seem random and expensive.

You can't explain your own financial statements.

They can't answer basic questions about comparable rents.

Vacancies that drag past 45 days.

Impossible to reach — emails take days.

They resist any discussion of capital improvements.

Any one of these costs you money. Several together cost you serious money.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

• Why Development Experience Changes Property Management

Most property managers have only managed occupied buildings. They've never built, renovated, or repositioned one.

Our company was built on multifamily development and value-add repositioning. We manage prop erties with construction knowledge, long-term capital planning, and the mindset of someone who's held buildings through full market cycles. We didn't start managing because it seemed like a good business — we started because we owned properties and got tired of managers who didn't understand ours.

The practical difference: when a contractor quotes $8,500 for a water heater, we know that's high because we've bought hundreds. When we see deferred maintenance, we don't just flag it — we scope the fix, estimate real costs, and build a timeline. When we evaluate a property, we think about where it needs to be in 2030, not just whether rent got collected this month.

• What to Do Next (Here's a hint - reach out to us!)

Free Property Management Analysis -  Send us your property details and your last 3 months of management statements. We'll provide an honest assessment of whether professional management makes sense, a market rent analysis for your specific units, a review of your current management performance, and identification of any missed opportunities.

No-pressure consultation. We'd rather give good advice than make a quick sale.

Not ready to switch?  Download our free checklist: "12 Questions to Ask Your Property Manager This Month." Use it to evaluate your current management — if they can't answer clearly, you're probably not getting the service you deserve.

Questions?  Call (626) 610-4889 or email info@helixrem.com. We help property owners make informed decisions — whether that involves working with us or not.

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────

About Helix Real Estate Management: Pasadena-based property management with roots in multifamily development and value-add repositioning. We manage properties with an owner's mindset, construction knowledge, and long-term vision. Serving Pasadena, Glendale, Burbank, Los Angeles, Long Beach, Torrance, and expanding throughout LA and Orange Counties. Learn more at www.helixrem.com!

────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────